Some highlights of the latest EDA I’ve read (The Last Resort).
I took these screens while reading, along with my reactions. As usual, this is full of spoilers.
What happened. No seriously, what happened.
I should love this book. It's written by Paul Leonard. His "worst" EDA so far was Dreamstone Moon, and I rated it 7/10 and even made fanart about it. His previous books were full of emotion, examined what it means to be human, what made a person a person even when they looked completely alien, talked about cosmic tragedies viewed from a small, personal angle. And now, here's a book where the stakes are higher than ever, and suddenly, nobody cares about anything.
From one scene to the next, we're following different versions of the same characters interchangeably. People die again and again, and little to no weight is given to any of it. We're told Sabbath and maybe the Doctor have a plan to solve the whole situation, but we can't parse what it is, so we don't really care. There's a lot of technobabble. About a third of the way into the story, it gets obvious that all of this is going to get hit by a big red RESET button at the end, so you're just waiting for it to happen. Thankfully, there's some very good imagery near the end, but it's too little too late.
It took me two years to get through The Last Resort. It's experimental, exhausting, convoluted but not complex, weirdly one-dimensional for a thing about multiple realities colliding, and more than a bit nihilistic. I want to care about things again, please. 3,5/10
Should I be scared
Oh ok that looks like a headache and a half
GODDDDD STOP IT
Oh, Time tourism! What could possibly go wrong
Wow okay apparently we're starting with self-murder
Hello Fitz, who's apparently currently working at a tourist trap. Also I'm surprised you don't want a cigarette instead of a beer, my guy
Just picturing Fitz trying to use excel makes me smile
And it's a shitty job too!
Oh so it's a direct continuation of the previous book!
Oh my god
UH OH
Me whenever nostalgia hits me and I forget how horrible that year actually was for teenage me
What's going onnnnn
UH OH 2: ELECTRIC BOOGALOO
And now we're in a completely different setting
Fuckin hell
This is starting to feel like a Fredric Brown novel
fuckin hell 2: the fuckinhellening
DOO EEE OOOOOOOOOOO
I'm gonna be perfectly honest, I didn't expect the two threads to connect so quickly
What a nightmare
Suddenly I feel really old
HELP
Brand new sentences
They're gonna kill that kid aren't they
He's dead he's dead he's so dead
CALLED IT
Hold on.What
Ok, that's new. Not gonna lie I was scared we were going to repeat that entire chapter
This is getting complicated
Not that I'm complaining but still
I swear to god if it repeats that same structure again in the next chapter
I know this is supposed to feel clever but it feels like padding
COME ON
[at this point I basically put the book down for an entire year]
Ok let's try this again
Ok. Ok. So now we have a version of the first chapter 2 where the kid doesn't die. Hopefully we're getting somewhere.
Yes, actually
Ok so Fitz saved this version of the kid
I was about to say "He changed a lot since his first books" and now I remember he's a clone and that's it, I'm sad once again. I will never, ever be over this
Very helpful
REAL
Oof??
Not to be mean or anything, but so far it was better the first time around
Oh no it's a different Anji
jesus christ, kid
Fitz no
Thanks for explaining the plot I guess
Not Sabbath again
Very funny description
Ohhhhh new location?
What now
I love this description
This is all very Dreamstone Moon
Wait. Were they living on the moon
I assume this is the regular Anji?
I missed you Anji
Cute
Well that explains some things
Have I mentioned I really like Iyeeye
Ok this time we're REALLY getting somewhere. I hope
Credit where it's due, this is the first time I'm picturing the Jonah clearly
I must admit I never thought about that before
Are they going to dethrone Cheops by recruting Akhenaton
Wait what the fuck
Must protect Iyeeye at all costs
Iyeeye feels like she's being treated like a tool not a person and now I'm sad too
Ohhhhhh. It's the mystery stowaway again. I had forgotten about that
Not Anji's proudest moment right there
I think I'm ready to call it: this book is a mess
jesus
Also known as Jakhenaton
Please don't do that
What now
Not sure, uh?
Cool imagery
MANYKHENATON
I don't care that much because people keep dying and not dying again and again in this book, but Fitz's reaction makes me really sad
Thank you for explaining stuff to me, Anji's journal, cause I'm starting to lose the plot a little bit. Or more accurately, I never really grasped the plot
Yeah I also need an aspirin
Nooooooooooo Fitz nooooooo
Oh we're getting more info on the stowaway?
I love this entire discussion
Okay
Your name is now officially Tix
YES thank you Eight for interrupting another repetition of the same scene. And also where were you
Basically same cause you lost me again
I hate to be that kind of guy, but Caerdroia did this kind of thing so much better
Thanks, Eight, very helpful
He doesn't even care anymore
Yeah same, Anji, everything felt so weightless I stopped reading for six months. Again. But now we're back
Welp, nevermind, just like that I want to draw Doctor Who fanart again. What a cool concept for a TARDIS room! I love it
Why is this funny
YESSSSSSSSS welcome back suicidal Eight I've missed you
I mean, same
Really cool description of time-travel
That's bleak and I feel kind of burnt out by this entire plot not even two-thirds into this book
Okay but if you all don't care and if the story doesn't care and if I no longer care who's flying this TARDIS
FACTS
Akhenaton at the burger place, what will he get
Time-travel racism. Or timeism. Or something
Yeah Ak I also like that Enter Shikari track why are you asking
This could have been such a good book
Well this is even harsher currently
Well congrats, you turned Akhenaton into a nihilist
Brand new sentences
Me trying to make friends
Yeah soooo everyone's character is kinda unravelling at this point
GO IYEEYE
Ok so. This book came out in 2003, but after talking with my friends it turns out there were already plans for another trilogy back then. So it's not a prediction or anything, but it's still pretty cool
Yeah same
Ok so on one hand this plan to steal his own dead body is all very diet coke Alien Bodies. On the other hand I like the idea of the identical guards. Like you decided one guy was very good at his job and decided you needed a second one so you just recruited the same guy again in a different reality
You mean the current zeitgeist?
Okay this is getting kinda worrying I must admit
Oh yeah reality is cooked
That specific plot point is a bit too realistic
This is starting to make sense again and I like the imagery
This was clever, but considering reality is collapsing on itself at this very moment I'm not entirely sure it's gonna be very helpful
yEAH EXACTLY, JESUS FUCKING CHRIST
YOU THINK??
Oh NO
Oh my god the imagery is really cool
"I'm very sorry but we all have to die". Quintessential Eight shit. Terrible job everyone
Again, the imagery of that sequence is insane
Anji just killed herself instead of watching millions of versions of herself die. Kind of a mood
OH MY GOD
I'm feeling a strange mix of not giving a fuck and existential terror about not giving a fuck
The CAUSALITY LOOP is CLOSING
Soooooooo kind of a less interesting version of the Unnoticed, then
Let's hit the reset button and kill 3 million versions of the TARDIS team
I'm tired
I'm so tired
I want to get off Mr Leonard's wild ride
Make it stop
Oh. Okay. My bad.
Uhhhhh if you say so I guess
Iyeeye deserved a better story
Nooooooo :(
I think they should be friends :)
Akhenaton of the stars! :D
At least there's a good ending to this mess.
No comments:
Post a Comment